What AI Can’t Replace: The Human Sales Skills Still Winning Deals

This is an excerpt from an article published by Sales and Marketing Management.

Several years back, researchers analyzed 103 million hands of online poker.

To their surprise, they discovered that the best hand wins only 12 percent of the time. Turns out, the best player wins 88 percent of the time, no matter what cards they’re dealt.

Sales organizations have been in frenzy to adopt AI. But just like those poker players, your success doesn’t depend on having the best technology. Your sales organization needs the best players—sellers who are highly skilled at reading the situation and guiding buyers through complex decisions.

In other words: Human sellers remain the decisive factor in winning complex deals, despite AI’s promise to automate everything from prospecting to pricing.

And there’s science to back this up.

Let’s dive into what the evidence says about winning in this environment.

Do Buyers Really Benefit from AI?

Despite unprecedented access to AI-powered research and evaluation tools, today’s B2B buyers are struggling more than ever to make confident decisions.

Research we conducted with Dr. Leff Bonney and Florida State University’s Sales Institute reveals a fascinating paradox: The more information and automation your buyers have access to, the less confident they become in their decisions.

This is due to what behavioral scientists call Escalation of Commitment. Buyers conduct a lot of self-directed research, they get locked into their assumptions, and they resist changing course—even when better options emerge.

Two underlying psychological forces make Escalation of Commitment particularly challenging for sales today:

  1. Sunk Cost Fallacy: Having invested heavily in research before engaging sellers, buyers resist abandoning their initial conclusions
  2. Cognitive Dissonance: They actively dismiss information that challenges their technology-guided assumptions

While AI excels at facilitating transactions, it increases buyers’ need for skilled human sellers who can challenge their assumptions and guide complex decisions. In fact, according to our data, better human selling experiences could have led to different outcomes in 53 percent of lost deals.

So what does that better human sales experience look like?

Read the full article (ungated) to see what skills sellers need to master in the age of AI.

Related Posts
11 Surprisingly Effective Sales Techniques, Backed by Research
Improve how you sell with this collection of the best B2B selling techniques, scientifically tested to...
The Great 8 for Acquisition: Sales Competencies That Win New Business
Buyer feedback shows 53 percent of lost deals were winnable. Discover the Great 8 seller competencies...
The Emblazers Podcast, Ep. 15: The Data Behind Top Performers - Dr. Peter Kerr's Sales Research
Amanda DeVlugt, Tim Riesterer, and special guest co-host Dr. Leff Bonney sit down with Dr. Peter Kerr,...
About the Author
Tim Riesterer

Tim Riesterer

Tim Riesterer, Chief Strategy Officer at Corporate Visions, is the sought after expert on evidence-based revenue growth using counterintuitive approaches. Known for his candid thought leadership and engaging keynotes, he’s spent decades testing and refining go-to-market strategies that put buyers squarely at the center. Tim is the author of four insightful books, including Customer Message Management, Conversations that Win the Complex Sale, The Three Value Conversations, and The Expansion Sale.